Monday, June 2, 2014

HOW YOUNG IS TOO YOUNG? A Look into the World of Child High Glitz Beauty Pageants Shown through TLC’s Toddlers & Tiaras

In January of 2009 TLC Network began airing a reality show entitled Toddlers & Tiaras, which chronicles mothers and their young girls as they navigate the cutthroat world of high glitz child beauty pageants. This show is currently in its sixth season, has over two million viewers, and has racked up tons of controversy over the years (IMDb). About three quarters of all of the episodes are currently available on Netflix. As someone who has watched all of the available episodes I have been able to come up with a few key points to understand about the world of child beauty pageants and the show. 

1) Most of the pageants featured on Toddlers & Tiaras are high glitz beauty pageants. This means that in order for the girls to be considers competitors at a pageant of this nature they are expected to have spray tans, fake nails, fake teeth, professionally done hair and makeup including wigs and fake eyelashes, and expensive outfits (Toddlers & Tiaras). Due to all of these necessary components for glitz pageants, most pageant families spend upwards of ten thousand dollars per year on pageants (Giroux, 2009).




2)  Most of the pageants feature two or three portions within the pageant, these include: the beauty portion, the themed outfit or outfit of choice potion, and the talent portion (which less than half of the pageants have). The beauty portion is weighted most heavily in terms of scoring. In beauty, the judges score the girls on facial beauty, smile, and how overall put together they appear (Toddlers & Tiaras).





3) Some of the most extreme examples of outfits on this show came from celebrity-themed pageants. One mother dressed her three-year-old up as Julia Robert’s character from Pretty Women. One mother had her daughter wear breast implants and butt implants in order to dress her up as Dolly Parton. And another mother barely clothed her daughter so that her daughter could portray Daisy Duke (Toddlers & Tiaras).




4) Each pageant has awards given out for each age division and then overall awards. Mothers always dread when their children are called to win an award in their age division, because that means that their child did not pull to win an overall or supreme title. Girls who win supreme titles usually receive: crowns, sashes, trophies, prizes and a monetary award in either cash or bonds ranging from fifty dollars to ten thousand dollars (Toddlers & Tiaras).




5) The girls on this show vary in age, but most range between one year and ten years old (Toddlers & Tiaras).




6) The vast majority of girls in this show were forced into pageants by their mothers when they were too young to protest. And among the older girls, probably less than half of them actually admit to liking pageantry (Toddlers & Tiaras).

 When children are forced into pageants at less than a year old Michel Foucault might say that the children are mere “docile bodies”. “Docile bodies” is a term that Foucault coins in his 1977 work Discipline and Punish. Docile is a term that literally means passive: for Foucault, a passive body is a body that has the ability to be manipulated. In his original work he discusses the notion of the “docile body” in relation to institutions such as the military and monasteries where the body is manipulated through strict discipline. This idea clearly applies to pageants as well; especially in instances where the children are too young to speak out against the related practices. Foucault says, “A body is docile that may be subjected, used, transformed and improved” (Foucault, 136). This is exactly what parents of babies and toddlers are doing in Toddlers & Tiaras. The parents subject their children’s bodies to transformation and “beauty improvements” by doing things to their children such as spray tanning them, putting makeup on them, and making them wear fake teeth – all without the consent of the child.  




As one might guess – based on the summary above – feminist blogs are a common source for criticism of the show. Two of the most popular feminist blogs to criticize Toddlers & Tiaras are Our-Turn-Feminism and Your Source for Feminist Discourse. The major concern on Our-Turn-Feminism is not with the nature of the beauty pageants themselves, but with the age of the children competing in them on the show. The blogger writes, “This is not one of those feminist rants against beauty pageants. Like sports, beauty pageants are a thing I have no interest in ever being near physically, but do enjoy watching movies about. (Drop Dead Gorgeous is a favorite of mine. I also like Mini Driver's Beautiful, and of course, Miss Congeniality. My problem with Toddlers & Tiaras is that... how young is too young for a beauty pageant?” (Our-Turn). I have to say that I personally agree with this statement. Bloggers who critique Toddlers & Tiaras – including myself – obviously watch the show. So, any critique that comes in good conscience is never going to be about the show itself; but rather, about a phenomenon illuminated by the show.

The question posed by the blogger above, “how young is too young”, is a unique question because it lacks a clear and objective answer. I’m yet to meet a feminist who believes that it is appropriate for toddlers to be made up to like adults or to be dressed up in costumes that are skimpy or sexual. But this inherently raises so many other questions, namely at what age does it become appropriate for children to be made up like adults for beauty pageants? If not age six, than age seven? Age ten? Age fifteen? Age seventeen? When they are adults? Never? Nobody really has a concrete answer. I think this only illustrates the nature of the issue. Age isn’t so much a concrete, numerical issue in terms of child beauty pageants – it is more of an issue of maturity – and it just so happens that age and maturity are developmentally linked. But I think the real question here is: when are children mature enough to enter into the world of child beauty pageants?

I realize that the way I frame the above question is rather loaded – it assumes that girls will indeed reach a time where they are “mature enough” to do pageants. And I don’t say that arbitrarily; I definitely do believe that there is a point where girls are mature enough for pageants. I believe that this point comes when girls are able to experience personal growth and development from doing pageants.

In the following video clip, former Ms. Georgia winner Kim Gravel talks about just that.  Gravel now hosts a pageant show on Lifetime entitled Kim of Queens. One of the major differences between Kim of Queens and Toddlers & Tiaras is the age and maturity level of the competitors. Gravel mentions how she prefers to only work with girls between the ages of twelve and eighteen because they can appreciate pageants for more than just being dolled up. In watching the video clip you will see that Gravel states that she believes, “every girl is a pageant girl”, and that pageants are about developing inner beauty, identity, talent, confidence, leadership, perseverance, and many other qualities… and not in any way about external beauty “or the outer shell” as she deems it (Gravel, Kim). If beauty pageants really can be understood in this way, than it seems that they would not be so detrimental to femininity and to the feminist movement. 


I very much agree with what Kim, I believe that beauty pageants can be views in a positive way.  I grew up all of my life as a competition dancer, and that world places tons of importance on external looks. During that stage of my life I was definitely influenced by all of the glitz and glamour around me. But today, as a more mature nineteen year old young women reflecting back on that era of my life, it is all of internal qualities that dance taught me such a dedication, drive, mental toughness, and perseverance that I appreciate the most.

The vast majority of the girls I see on Toddlers & Tiaras say that the do pageants because they are beautiful, or for the money, or to win. This just suggests that the girls on this show are not mature enough to appreciate pageants on a deeper level. This raises the common concern that putting young girls in beauty pageants teaches them that all of their value and self-worth comes from their beauty and appearance. A blogger on Your Source for Feminist Discourse writes, “Moms claim that girls who partake in these kinds of competitions have higher self-esteem than other girls their age. Well, unfortunately that’s probably a true statement, but it’s important to consider where this confidence is coming from. If your daughter’s sense of self is coming solely from the praise she receives based on her appearance, then that’s a problem. The result is child who learns her only worthy asset is the way she looks and her ability to “work it” a child-sized Madonna-inspired cone-shaped bustier” (What’s Wrong with Toddlers & Tiaras).

This is of course a much larger issue than just in beauty pageants. Child beauty pageants may be considered the ideal stage for beauty or the perfect situation for femininity based on beauty because, “beauty pageants judge contestants based on both their outer and “inner beauty” however, it is clear the outer beauty is the determining factor. Pageant contestants are considered to be the epitome of ideal beauty in American society” (Connolly, 36). The extent of a women’s value being placed of her beauty is a societal problem in America; it just so happens to be clearly illustrated in the microcosm of beauty pageants. In her revolutionary 1991 novel The Beauty Myth, Naomi Wolf discusses how the relation between a women’s success and a women’s power extends to the workplace as well. She writes, “By the 1980s beauty has come to play in women’s status-seeking the same role as money plays in that of men: a defensive proof to aggressive competitors of womanhood or manhood” (Wolf, 30). To put this into blunt and simple terms, Wolf is trying to argue that the prettier women will always get the job. A critic of Wolf’s book derives the following message from it, “Want to get hired? Land an important client? Snag a promotion? Simply keep your job? Better have your hair, nails, skin, weight, and wardrobe in flawless condition. A set of constantly-shifting standards combined with a no-win balancing act between looking "too attractive" and opening oneself up to legally-protected sexual harassment and "not attractive enough" to keep one's job is the result” (Feminist Book Review).

I can personally attest to the truth of the above statements. I am currently at the stage in my life where I am going to a lot of job interviews and internships – and I can one hundred percent say that I would never dream of going to a job interview without my hair straightened, nice make up, French-manicured nails, and a nice outfit – because I know, that no matter how smart I might be, or no matter how qualified I am for the position, my appearance will still be judged all in the same.

Obviously I am able to enough distance myself from beauty standards in order to be able to write the blog post; but I still admit to feeling pressured by beauty standards. Imagine how three, and four, and five year olds feel when they are forced into a world where beauty is everything? They don’t have the mental and psychological maturity to understand that inner beauty in fact a thing. They learn based on their environments; and the pageants teach them that outer beauty, winning, and money are everything.

The following video clip is from season one episode six of Toddlers & Tiaras, it introduces the audience to the six year old contestant Karmen and her mother Heather, and chronicles their preparation for the pageant. In this video Karmen appears very superficial, associating beauty to makeup, sparkles, and glitter. But it’s absolutely impossible to blame her. This is because her mother is seen forcing Karmen to get a spray tan even though she is in tears of discomfort and forcing Karmen to wear fake teeth even though she has a beautiful smile. In fact, Heather even attributes her daughter’s winning streak not to any internal qualities of her daughter, but rather, to the fake teeth (Toddlers & Tiaras, Karmen’s Mom). 


Personally for me, watching little Karmen cry in the tanning booth and cry at the pageant for being tired and starving is extremely hard for me to watch. In fact, there are some critiques of the show out there and claim that Toddlers and Tiaras verges on child abuse. According to the Oxford Encyclopedia of Psychology, child abuse is defined as “the physical, emotional, or sexual maltreatment of a child”. Physical abuse is anything cruel or undue that causes physical pain or puts the child in physical risk. Emotional abuse “lack of affection or hostility that damages a child’s emotional development” (Coleman, Child Abuse).

Below are two video clips that illustrate the physical abuse associated with beauty pageants. The first video is a clip from a Doctor Phil interview with Toddlers & Tiaras mom Lori Matthews who faced harsh criticism for dyeing her daughter’s eyelashes and bleaching her daughter’s teeth. Doctor Phil reviews with her all of the extensive health risks that come from these extreme beauty practices ((Dr. Phil. HD: Pageant Mom: Did She Put Her Daughter In Danger?). This, along with the mother’s defensive attitude, highlight how the mother’s put their young daughters at risk for physical damage through pageants. 




The second clip is of a Toddlers & Tiaras mother forcing her five year old daughter to get her eyebrows
waxed. For about the entirety of the clip the girl can be seen crying and wrenching in physical pain and distress – but, this means nothing to the mother as she forces her daughter to go through with the waxing. 


Another way in which pageants can be abusive to young children is emotionally. Author and Professor Henry Giroux discusses all of the risks that pageants girls face for developing psychological disorders later in life in his 2009 critique of child beauty pageants. He writes, “organizations such as the American Psychological Association Task Force on the Sexualization of Girls,  issued a report indicating a strong connection between young girls who have to endure a premature emphasis on sex and appearance and "three of the most common mental health problems of girls and women: eating disorders, low self-esteem and depression."[8] Other child psychologists insists that the intense competition at pageants, coupled with the nomadic lifestyle of traveling from one hotel to another when school is not in session, makes it difficult for young children to make friends, putting them at risk for developing a number of problems in their social interactions with other children. Moreover, some child specialists argue that it is as developmentally inappropriate to "teach a six-year-old to pose like a twenty-year-old model as it is to allow her to drive [and] drink alcohol."[9] Of course, there is also the stress of competition and the danger of undermining a child's self-confidence, especially when she loses, if the message she receives is that how she looks is the most important aspect of who she is” (Giroux, 2009).

An example of a mother emotionally abusing her young daughter for the sake of winning pageants can be seen in this video clip below. In this video clip competitive mother Melissa is speaking to her shy six year old daughter Carley – or Darla. Darla is a sassy diva alter ego that Melissa has forced her daughter to adopt for pageants. While putting the last minute preparation on her daughter Melissa flat out tells her daughter that she better have left Carley – or her true self – in the car. She continues on to threaten her daughter and exclaim that it better be Darla present, because Darla is more likely to win the pageant (Toddlers & Tiaras – Multiple Personalities). Melissa essentially neglects her daughter Carley for the sake of her own competitive drive and desire to win the pageant. 


The last idea that is important to discuss further is the sexualization of young girls. Whether or not the moms on Toddlers and Tiaras realize it, by dressing up their daughters to look like women and then featuring them on a national television show, they leave their daughters wide open to sexual predators. This is exactly what happened to Lori Matthew’s nine year old daughter Alaska. This incident is discussed in detail in the later part of the interview that Dr. Phil has with Lori. A photo of Alaska taken from the show ended up on an adult site entitled thedirty.com, where an elder gentleman posted that he performed sexual acts to Alaska’s photo. Joining Lori and Dr. Phil for the later part of the interview is Nick Richie, the owner of thedirty.com, and ultimately the man who allowed the photo and the risqué comments of Alaska to remain on the website. In the interview Nick explains how he allowed the picture to remain on the website in hopes of sending a message to other pageant moms that putting dressing their daughters up like women and then putting them on a national television show is exploitative of their daughters and leaves them at risk for attention from sexual predators (Dr. Phil. HD: Pageant Mom: Did She Put Her Daughter In Danger?). 


There has obviously been a lot discussed and a lot of sources reviewed in this post; yet it is still difficult to wrap up in any sort of decisive way. However, if there were two main points that I want one to be able to take away from this post they would be the following.

1) Toddlers & Tiaras places children in the superficial and competitive world of high glitz beauty pageants before they are emotionally and psychologically mature enough to separate their own sense of value and self-worth from external beauty. This can inhibit the emotional development of these girls and leave them open to a plethora of psychological disorders at an older age.

2) Mothers of contestants on Toddlers & Tiaras can be abusive to their children by forcing them through extensive pageant preparation rituals that are painful and potentially dangerous. The nature of Toddlers & Tiaras in and of itself is sexually exploitative of the contestants because it nationally publicized these little girls as being older and more sexually mature than they actually are.



Lastly, I want to leave everyone with some food for thought. The research and discussion that I have done on this topic leads me to make the following claim: pageant moms on the show Toddlers & Tiaras demonstrate a relationship to pageants that resembles a relationship between a drug addict and an abusive substance. However, instead of harming only themselves by using the substance: they force their daughters to use and harm their daughters as well. According to the American Psychological Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual in order to be diagnosed with Substance Use Disorder there are a list of twelve symptoms and one must possess at least two of them.



Think about Lori Matthew’s, the pageant mom who was interviewed by Dr. Phil. She admitted that it started out as just one pageant – but then she saw paperwork for another, and another, and another… and it became an almost weekly thing for her children. In the DSM-V, one possible behavior listed is, “Substance is often taken in larger amounts or over a longer period than was intended” (American Psychological Association, 2013). This is definitely the case for Lori and her family. Another thing that Lori mentioned is the extensive pageant preparation rituals that she puts her children though – including eyelash dying and teeth bleaching. Another possible symptom listed in the DSM-V is “A great deal of time is spent in activities necessary to obtain substance, use the substance, or recover from its effects” (American Psychological Association, 2013). With the amount of time that Lori spends prepping her children, this is definitely the case. Additionally, as Dr. Phil points out, the eyelash dyeing is potentially extremely hazardous, but Lori continues to do it anyways. This behavior matches up with the following symptom “Recurrent substance use in situations in which it is physically hazardous” (American Psychological Association, 2013). The last thing that Lori did that really stuck out as being extremely harmful to her nine-year-old daughter is refusing to remove her from the pageant world after the pictures of her daughter surfaced on the adult website. In this instance for Lori “substance use is continued despite having knowledge of having a persistent or recurrent physical or psychological problem that is likely to have been caused or exacerbated by the substance” (American Psychological Association, 2013). 



And with that, Lori Matthews has met more than the required number of symptoms to be diagnosed with Substance Use Disorder. To put in in Lori’s own words, “I’m not addicted, but pageants are addicting” (Dr. Phil. HD: Pageant Mom: Did She Put Her Daughter In Danger?). 

~ Sarah Margulis, Philosophy Student, Drexel University
   Project Completed for Philosophy 481 - Feminist Philosophy
   Spring Quarter, 2013-2014


*********************************************************************************

Works Cited

American Psychiatric Association. (2013). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (5th ed.). Arlington, VA:  American Psychiatric Publishing.

"Child Abuse? Mother Forces Her 5-Year-Old Daughter TO Wax Her Eyebrows On "Toddlers & Tiaras"!." YouTube. YouTube, n.d. Web. 2 June 2014. <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GEvo6Eau-Xg>.

Colman, Andrew. "Child Abuse" A Dictionary of Psychology. 3rd ed. 2008.Oxford Reference. Web. 1 June 2014.

Connolly, Corrinne N., ""Baby, I wish we could get you some lips for Christmas": investigating cultural disregard for girls through the promotion of hegemonic and sexualized femininity, and celebrity in Toddlers & Tiaras" (2011).Communication Studies Master's Theses. Paper 2.http://hdl.handle.net/2047/d20001047

"Dr Phil HD: Pageant Mom: Did She Put Her Daughter in Danger ? (November 26, 2013)." YouTube. YouTube, n.d. Web. 2 June 2014. <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aIMYG-dSGqU>.

"Feminist Book Review: The Beauty Myth by Naomi Wolf." Examiner.com. N.p., n.d. Web. 1 June 2014. <http://www.examiner.com/review/feminist-book-review-the-beauty-myth-by-naomi-wolf>.

Foucault, Michel. "Docile Bodies." Discipline and punish: the birth of the prison. New York: Pantheon Books, 1977. 141-169. Print.

Giroux, Henry. "TruthOut Archive." Child Beauty Pageants: A Scene From the "Other America". N.p., 11 May 2009. Web. 1 June 2014. <http://www.truth-out.org/archive/component/k2/item/84012:child-beauty-pageants-a-scene-from-the-other-america>.

"Our Turn: Feminism for Newbies." : Toddlers & Tiaras. N.p., n.d. Web. 1 June 2014. <http://our-turn-feminism.blogspot.com/2010/12/toddlers-tiaras.html>.

"The "Kim Of Queens" Kim Gravel Joins JD And Rebecca In The Studio." Better Show. N.p., n.d. Web. 1 June 2014. <http://better.tv/view/celebrities-celebrities2-the--quot-kim-of-queens-quot--kim-gravel-joins-jd-and-rebecca-in-the-studio>.

"Toddlers and Tiaras." IMDb. IMDb.com, n.d. Web. 1 June 2014. <http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1364951/?ref_=nv_sr_1>.

"Toddlers & Tiaras - Karmen's Mom."YouTube. YouTube, n.d. Web. 1 June 2014. <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ORcBTC7TiVY>.

"Toddlers & Tiaras - Multiple Personalities." YouTube. YouTube, n.d. Web. 2 June 2014. <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zo9Fz-iyW8A>.

 “Toddlers & Tiaras.” TLC. Authentic Entertainment. Television. 2009-2014.

"What's Wrong with Toddlers in Tiaras."ShoutOut JMU: Your Source for Feminist Discourse. N.p., n.d. Web. 1 June 2014. <http://jmuwomensstudentcaucus.wordpress.com/2011/09/23/whats-wrong-with-toddlers-in-tiaras/>.

Wolf, Naomi. The beauty myth: how images of beauty are used against women. New York: W. Morrow, 1991. Print.












No comments:

Post a Comment